THE DIGITAL TOWN SQUARE'S TOWN SQUARE
Here's What We Learned From Elon Musk's Q&A On Twitter Spaces
On November 9, Elon Musk hosted a Q&A in Twitter Spaces, open to the public. The session was hosted by Twitter’s Client Solutions Leader Robin Wheeler, who was joined by Musk, Twitter’s Trust & Safety Head Yoel Roth and International Advertising Bureau CEO David Cohen.
— Robin Wheeler (@robinw) November 9, 2022
Journalists and listeners on Twitter reported that the session was fairly unstructured, meandering between the big topics Musk has been talking about since he started working to purchase the platform: his desire for Twitter to be “a force for good for civilization,” his ideas about monetization and user verification.
A few takeaways, transcribed in Tech Crunch’s coverage and from Twitter:
On his goals for the platform
We really want to be, as I’ve mentioned before publicly, sort of the digital town square, where that is as inclusive as possible… Like, can we get 80% of humanity on Twitter, and talking, and maybe, ideally, in a positive way? Can we exchange… instead of having violence, have words, and maybe once in a while people change their minds? The overarching goal here is like, how can we make Twitter a force for good for civilization?
On verification
Someone has to have phone, a credit card and $8 a month. That’s the bar.
On controlling spam, trolls and fake accounts
The issue is that creating a fake account is extremely cheap, it maybe is a tenth of a penny,” he said. “By charging $8 a month, it raises the cost of a bot or troll by somewhere between 1,000 and 10,000.
Wouldn’t a state actor have $8 million a day to create a million fake accounts? Well, yes, they’ve got the budget. But here’s the problem. They don’t have a million credit cards, and they don’t have a million phones. That’s the actual kicker. There’s no way to overcome that. And we will be vigorously pursuing any impersonation.
On the reach of different users’ tweets
Over time, maybe not that long of time, when you look at mentions and replies and what not, the default will be to look at verified. You can still look at unverified, just as in your gmail or whatever, you can still look at the probable spam folder,” Musk said. “You can still look at all the others, but it will be defaulted to the highly, highly relevant category, which will be verified.
#TwitterTakeover
— Ellie Sennett (@EllieMSennett) November 9, 2022
Mega billionaire Elon Musk is hosting a live Q&A on Twitter right now on advertising on the platform he recently took over
He says he sees a paywall as the best way to mitigate 'noisy' hateful conduct on the platform
Elon Musk currently speaking on Twitter explaining a goal of having peer-to-peer payments and money market accounts https://t.co/x2w7mru5jg
— Jimmy Lovaas (@jimmylovaas) November 9, 2022
"If things go wrong it's my fault. The buck stops with me", @elonmusk
— Chandra R. Srikanth (@chandrarsrikant) November 9, 2022
"The best way to see how things are evolving is to just use Twitter"
"Content is actually improving"
Reactions to what Musk said ranged from the optimistic to the critical. In terms of positive reactions, people seemed to appreciate that the meeting was held in an open forum, and that Musk seemed genuinely interested in answering questions and thinking things through aloud.
Over 110,000 people listening to Elon explain and answer questions re:Twitter's future on Spaces is already a massive change from the previous management style.https://t.co/o5sHrYmdqO
— markopohlo.eth (@marko_pohlo) November 9, 2022
In which Elon being clear, consistent, slightly jokey and not wack memelord works. So far, so good. Still not paying $8, since he’s being nonspecific about value and it’s still all lords and peasants hand waving — Twitter set it up this way not us. https://t.co/kSJeSq8Q1z
— Kara Swisher (@karaswisher) November 9, 2022
On the flip side, other people found the talk unfocused and Musk’s ideas concerning. People are doubtful of one particular claim that Musk seems very confident about: that if people have to pay to use Twitter, they’ll behave better on it.
Elon: "In the United States we fought a war to get rid of this stuff"
— Katie Notopoulos (@katienotopoulos) November 9, 2022
[this stuff = how some people don't have checkmarks]https://t.co/3gUfKrJ3zx
I wish @karaswisher and @CaseyNewton were hosting this. They’d be asking much tougher questions. https://t.co/RaUEiEXz1f
— Scott Monty (@ScottMonty) November 9, 2022
Wow listening to @elonmusk talk during this Twitter spaces makes it clearer than ever that his goal with changes to verification is essentially to end anonymous speech on Twitter ... arguably one of the most anti free speech things he could do.
— Evan Greer is on Mastodon (@evan_greer) November 9, 2022
https://t.co/duqVpWF5Jn
Elon making the argument that people won’t pay $8 and engage in hateful content. So let’s bookmark that claim for later. https://t.co/hFZS8sT8E8
— Jason Goldman (@goldman) November 9, 2022
Musk has yet to make a decision about charging users for Twitter accounts, and it’s unclear how he’ll fulfill his goal of making Twitter a place for free speech while simultaneously suspending accounts making jokes about him. We’ll wait with bated breath for the next Twitter Spaces session.